The New Politics of the Budgetary Process
A rewriting of the earlier
The Politics of the Budgetary Process
First edition 1964
Calculations
(Chpt. 3)
"Budgeting is complex, both because there are many interrelated
items and because these often pose technical difficulties." (p. 73) "Endless
time and unlimited ability to calculate might help. But time is in short supply,
the human mind can encompass just so much, and the number of budgetary items
may be huge." (p. 74)
In other words: A totally "rational" budget is
(1) humanly impossible, because of complexity and limits of human understanding,
and
(2) undemocratic by denying that conflicts over fundamental purposes and
values means there is not a beginning point of agreement upon which to build
the "rational" analysis; democracy works through both compromise, not just
logic, to resolve conflict.
"Budgeting in consensual. There must be agreement on the general direction of public policy." (p. 76)
"Budgeting is historical. One way of dealing with a problem of huge magnitude is to make rough guesses while letting experience accumulate." (p. 76)
"Budgets are made in fragments." (p. 77)
"Budgeting is incremental. The largest determining factor of this
year's budget if last year's." (p. 78)
An Effective Budget Officer for a Program or Department is a Good Politician
Clientele: to develop a clientele effective in supporting the finical needs of the program.
Confidence: to establish trust, by legislators and others, in the budget officer (that information is correct and complete, expectations are honest, etc.); important in gaining an attentive audience for explaining, and making the case for, programs.
Contingent strategies: to understand the special circumstances of the times (e.g. how tight is the budget, what are special public demands), to relate programs and requests for resources to these circumstance.