Sensitivity to cost
• High (to consumer, and somewhat to provider) if
paid
by consumer
• Low if paid by third party (private insurance,
government)
Coverage
• Who is covered:
Private insurance by ability/willingness to pay?
Public insurance by population subgroups?
• What is covered: acccording to
procedure, health condition, provider type, etc.?
Redistributive effects
• Commercial health insurance: from those
with low health expenditures to those with high health expenditures
• Government health insurance: same, plus
from high tax payers to low tax payers
Competition in budgeting
|
|
|
| Federal govt. | retirement income (social security) |
| State govt. | education |
| Employer | pay check |
| Individual | personal consumption |
Bargaining positions of payer and provider
• Provider in stronger position with many payers, as
with
small private insurers.
• Payer in stronger position when covering many
lives, e.g. Medicare
Relative tax base and migration of patients
seeking financing of care
Federal government:
TAX BASE: strong
MIGRATION: limited to foreign citizens
State governments:
TAX BASE: competing with other states for economic
growth
(low taxes and expenditures for physical infrastructure and education -
not
social services)
MIGRATION: concerned that good benefit plans will
attract
the ill from other states as well as from other nations